Skip to content
Orbit Club

A United Ireland Plebiscite Cannot Transform Into 'Another Brexit', Analysts Caution

A decade after the UK entered into a hurried referendum that divided the nation and triggered turmoil, a warning comes from across the Irish Sea: it could happen again.

Authorities and electorate entered unwittingly Brexit and the same might transpire with a referendum on a united Ireland, initiating upheavals for which no one is prepared.

That represents the warning from two prominent journalists from either side of the Irish border who have joined forces to examine the benefits and drawbacks of Northern Ireland leaving the UK to establish a fresh nation with the Republic of Ireland.

Governmental Structures Not Ready

The author and columnist and Sam McBride, have concluded that the government bodies in Ireland and Britain are woefully unready for a potentially contentious and transformative public vote.

"The lesson of Brexit has gone unabsorbed, which is that stuff can emerge unexpectedly and can gain traction very quickly," O’Toole remarked. "I would suggest that the institutional structure of our region remains extremely volatile."

New Title Intends to Provoke Discussion

The pair have studied the political, financial and societal rationales for any constitutional change in a publication, The Case For and Against Unification, published by the Dublin-based Royal Irish Academy.

They aim to encourage dialogue on the issue with a roadshow of public talks that will lead them to Westminster early next month.

"What troubles everyone, or should haunt everybody, is the Brexit vote of 2016," said O’Toole.

"We must avoid a referendum on a binary, ambiguous question whose implications have not been clarified because then you find yourself with an highly polarised community where the losing side are unable to accept defeat and the victorious side don't know exactly what it is that they have achieved."

Governmental Mandate

Under the Good Friday agreement, the Northern Ireland official is obliged to schedule a public vote on Irish unity if it seems probable that a most voters would approve.

Nationalist parties and other nationalists argue this point is looming, and a organisation named Ireland’s Future has garnered backing, but authorities in Dublin and London and pro-UK factions downplay the possibility, making it uncertain when or if there could be a referendum.

Absence of Informed Dialogue

Partisan language for and against unification has obscured the shortage of informed dialogue, said the journalist.

"People tend to be for or against the idea but the concrete planning which may surpass that to realise it hasn't for the most part happened. A lot has occurred in universities but very few elected officials or activists seek to involve themselves even with the basics. To illustrate, which kind of country would you want? Unitary? Federal?"

Book's Approach

In the publication, none of the commentators endorses unification or the current situation. Both composes two articles that seek impartiality in presenting the case for a unified Ireland and the argument against, assembling financial and social figures, past examples and governmental frameworks.

Debates cover identity markers, taxes, healthcare systems, elderly benefits, national debt responsibilities and the risk of loyalist violence. The aim is to inform and provoke discussion.

"Considerable attention exists in the subject but there has not yet occurred a debate," commented O’Toole. "Discussion implies an recognition of the notion that there may exist valid points on each side."

Dual Referendums

A referendum in Northern Ireland would simultaneously prompt one in the Republic of Ireland, where voters report they support unity but reject paying higher taxes or adopting a alternative symbol to acknowledge pro-UK communities' UK heritage.

"Authorities in Dublin does need to establish what the plan from Irish nationalism is aside from just saying: 'We desire a united Ireland and we welcome you'," stated O’Toole.

Likelihood of Referendum

McBride thinks a referendum in his lifetime is probable and that it might occur abruptly. "It is possible just a reckless or a poor or a feckless official who says: 'We should proceed and get it out of the way.'"

Both nationalists and pro-UK supporters have plausible, legitimate arguments, he commented. "One side will win on this issue and somebody will eventually lose but each side has has important lessons to gain from the other's positions."

Call for Wider Debate

Westminster needed to join the dialogue, stated O’Toole. "This is about Britain. It's a UK matter as much as it is an Irish issue."

The writer

Dr. Matthew Randolph

Elara Vance is an astrophysicist and science writer with a passion for making space accessible through engaging storytelling and research.

Orbit Club

Type to search articles.